Choosing the right trustee can feel like one of the most difficult decisions that you need to make, but nonetheless it is an important decision in your estate planning process. The trustee you select will manage the assets of the trust that you create, ensuring that your loved ones or even charitable interests are provided for according to your wishes. Understanding the distinctions between corporate trustees, professional trustees, and individual trustees can help you make an informed decision that best suits not only your family's needs but potentially your business interests as well. Let's explore the unique advantages and potential drawbacks of each trustee type to help you make this decision feel less difficult.
Disclaimer: The information provided is intended for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice.
Corporate Trustees
A corporate trustee is a legal entity, typically a bank, trust company, or other financial institution, that is appointed to manage and administer a trust.
Benefits of a Corporate Trustee:
Expertise and Resources: Corporate trust companies are usually staffed with professionals who have expertise in trust management, tax law, investments, and estate planning. This ensures that the trust is managed in a knowledgeable and compliant manner.
Continuity and Stability: Unlike individual trustees, corporate trustees are not subject to personal circumstances such as illness, death, or incapacity. This longevity can ensure that the trust is managed consistently over time, which is particularly beneficial for long-term trusts.
Impartiality: Corporate trustees can provide an unbiased administration of the trust, avoiding potential conflicts of interest that might arise with family members or friends acting as trustees.
Regulated and Insured: Corporate trustees are typically regulated by governmental bodies and are required to adhere to strict fiduciary standards. They often have large levels of insurance coverage to protect against potential losses, which provides an additional layer of security for the trust's assets.
Mitigation of Family Conflict: By appointing a neutral corporate trustee, families can often avoid conflicts that might arise if a family member or friend were to serve as trustee, particularly in complex or contentious situations.
Specialized Services: Corporate trustees can offer specialized services such as managing complex assets (e.g., businesses, real estate) and providing tailored financial planning and trust services.
Disadvantages of a Corporate Trustee:
Cost: Corporate trustees often charge higher fees compared to individual trustees.
These fees can be a percentage of the trust assets and might include additional charges for specific services.
Lack of Personal Relationship: Corporate trustees may not have a personal relationship with the beneficiaries or a deep understanding of the family's dynamics and unique needs, which can impact the trust administration process.
Rigidity: Corporate trustees might adhere strictly to company policies and procedures, which can result in less flexibility in managing the trust compared to an individual trustee who can make more personalized decisions.
Impersonal Service: The service provided by a corporate trustee might feel more transactional and less personalized. Beneficiaries might not have a single point of contact and could deal with different representatives over time.
Potential Conflicts of Interest: If the corporate trustee is also a financial institution, there could be conflicts of interest in the investment decisions they make, potentially prioritizing their products or services.
Administrative Delays: Large corporate entities might have slower response times and more bureaucratic processes, leading to delays in decision-making and trust administration.
Lack of Local Presence: National or regional corporate trustees might not have a local presence, which can be a disadvantage for trusts that require hands-on management or for beneficiaries who prefer local interaction.
Limited Knowledge of Family Dynamics: A corporate trustee may lack the intimate knowledge of family dynamics and history that an individual trustee might have, which can impact their ability to make decisions that align with the trustor’s intentions.
Professional Trustees
Professional trustees are individuals holding a professional degree (such as attorneys and accountants) or legal entities (such as law firms or accounting firms), who provide fiduciary services as their profession. Professional trustees are appointed to ensure that a trust is managed effectively, impartially, and in accordance with legal and fiduciary standards.
Benefits of a Professional Trustee:
Expertise and Comprehensive Services: Professional trustees bring specialized knowledge in law, tax, or financial planning, providing tailored advice and management for your trust. Professional trustees can offer a wide range of services, including investment management, legal advice, tax planning, and estate planning, which can be tailored to the needs of the trust and its beneficiaries.
Professional Networks: Professional trustees often have access to a network of other professionals, such as legal advisors, tax experts, and financial planners, which can be leveraged to provide comprehensive trust management.
Personalized Service: Unlike corporate trustees, professional trustees can offer more personalized service, often developing a close relationship with the grantor and beneficiaries.
Flexibility: Professional trustees can be more flexible in decision making, adapting to the unique needs of the trust and its beneficiaries.
Regulated and Insured: Many professional trustees, are regulated by governmental bodies and carry insurance, providing additional security and oversight. For example, an attorney trustee should maintain malpractice insurance and is held to an ethical standard which, if not upheld, can disbar them for mismanagement of a trust.
Reduced Family Conflict: By acting as an impartial third party, professional trustees can help to minimize conflicts among beneficiaries and ensure that your intentions are honored.
Disadvantages of a Professional Trustee:
Fees Reflective of Professional Expertise: Professional trustees charge fees for their services. These fees can be statutory or may be more reflective of the specialized expertise and professional care they provide, ensuring the trust is managed effectively.
Availability and Continuity: A professional trustee might not offer the same level of continuity as a corporate trustee. Although many professional trustees prepare for their illness, retirement, or death, if such circumstance occurs, it can disrupt the administration of the trust and necessitate the appointment of a new trustee.
Geographical Limitations: For certain types of investment portfolios, professional trustees might be limited by their geographical location, which can be a disadvantage if the trust requires management of assets in different regions or countries that have cumbersome regulatory rules.
Limited Resources: Some, but not all, professional trustees do not have the extensive resources or large support staff that corporate trustees possess. This can result in a delay of administration.
Individual Trustees
An individual trustee is a person, often a friend or family member, who is appointed to manage and administer a trust according to its terms and the best interests of the beneficiaries. Unlike corporate or professional trustees, individual trustees are typically chosen for their personal relationship with the Grantor of the Trust (i.e. you) and the beneficiaries.
Benefits of an Individual Trustee:
Personal Connection: An individual trustee may have a deep personal connection to the family and has a deeper understanding of your wishes, family dynamics, and the needs of the beneficiaries. This personal insight can lead to more empathetic and tailored management of the trust.
Trusted Relationship: Beneficiaries may feel more comfortable and trusting with an individual trustee who they know personally. This can foster better communication and smoother administration of the trust.
Cost-Effective: Appointing a friend or family member as a trustee can be more cost-effective than hiring a professional trustee, as they may not charge the same fees or may only require minimal compensation.
Flexibility: Similar to professional trustees, individual trustees can offer a flexible, personalized approach to managing the trust. They can pivot their strategy to changing circumstances and make decisions that are closely aligned with your intentions.
Commitment and Loyalty: An individual trustee is often chosen because of their loyalty and commitment to the Grantor and beneficiaries. This personal dedication can ensure that the trustee is motivated by the best interests of the beneficiary rather than financial gain.
Simplicity and Accessibility: Having a trustee who is a friend or family member can simplify the administration process, making it easier for beneficiaries to ask questions, express concerns, and get timely responses.
Disadvantages of an Individual Trustee:
Lack of Expertise: Friends or family members may not have the same level of expertise or experience in trust management, tax laws, and investment strategies as professional trustees. This can lead to mistakes or suboptimal decisions.
Emotional Involvement and Potential for Bias: Personal relationships can sometimes complicate trust administration. Emotional involvement may lead to biased decisions or difficulty in enforcing the trust’s terms impartially. Even with the best intentions, a trustee who is a friend or family member might unconsciously favor certain beneficiaries over others, leading to perceptions of unfairness.
Time and Effort: Managing a trust can be time-consuming and complex. An individual trustee might find it challenging to balance these responsibilities with their personal and professional commitments.
Potential for Conflict: Disagreements among beneficiaries or between the trustee and beneficiaries can arise, particularly if the trustee is perceived to favor one beneficiary over another. These conflicts can strain personal relationships.
Liability and Risk: An individual trustee may be personally liable for any errors or breaches of fiduciary duty. Without professional training, they may be more susceptible to making decisions that expose them to legal risks.
Limited Resources and Support: Unlike corporate and professional trustees, individual trustees typically do not have access to a broad network of resources, support staff, or institutional knowledge. This can limit their ability to address complex trust issues efficiently.
Continuity Concerns: An individual trustee might become incapacitated, pass away, or be otherwise unable to continue their duties. This can create disruptions in the administration of the trust and necessitate the appointment of a successor trustee, which can be a complicated process involving the Court and potential litigation.
Summary
Selecting the right trustee is a big decision that impacts the future of your estate and your family's well-being. As you navigate the options, you might question your confidence that your chosen trustee will manage your business assets effectively and impartially. You may find yourself wondering whether your family and asset portfolio would benefit from a corporate or professional trustee, especially if you own a business. As experienced estate planning attorneys, LSS Law can guide you through this process, helping you make a choice that aligns with your values and goals. By addressing these critical aspects of trust management and trustee selection, you can ensure that your assets and family are well-protected, and your estate is managed according to your wishes. Contact us to schedule a consultation with one of our estate planning attorneys and take the first step towards securing your legacy.
Comments